Herod Returning Christ to Pilate

Red chalk counterproof on off-white antique laid paper, framing lines in black ink, adhered to cream antique laid paper, adhered to blue antique laid paper

Black chalk stumping on cream antique laid paper, framing lines in black ink, graphite, black chalk and green watercolor, laid down on cream antique laid paper

Black and white chalk on blue antique laid paper, laid down on cream antique laid paper

Black ink and black and gray wash, probably over graphite, framing lines in black ink, on off-white antique laid paper (laid down)

Red and white chalk on light tan antique laid paper, partial framing lines in black chalk and black ink, laid down on a decorated mount

Black and white chalk on light tan antique laid paper

Red chalk on toned cream antique laid paper

Brown ink, brown wash, and white gouache over black chalk, on cream antique laid paper, framing lines in black ink, mounted

Red chalk on off-white antique laid paper; verso: graphite

Watercolor and black ink over traces of graphite on off-white antique laid paper, adhered to cream antique laid paper

Pen with black and brown ink, gray wash, watercolor, and black chalk on cream antique laid paper, laid down on cream antique laid paper with blue paper strips adhered to face, framing lines in black ink

Black ink, two tones of gray wash, and traces of white gouache on off-white antique laid paper, framing lines in brown ink; verso: black ink and gray wash