Portrait of Madame Charles Hayard and Her Daughter Caroline

Black chalk, brown and gray wash, white gouache, and traces of graphite on cream wove paper

Black and white chalk on blue-gray antique laid paper, discolored to pale tan

Black and white chalk on gray-brown paper (possibly faded from blue)

Gouache on cardboard

Graphite on buff wove paper

Brown ink on thin tracing paper, darkened, and adhered to laid paper

Graphite on white wove paper

Graphite on cream wove paper

Graphite on off-white wove paper

Gray and tan wash over graphite on greenish antique laid paper; verso: graphite

Black crayon, squared in black crayon, on off-white antique laid paper

Brush and black ink over charcoal on off-white paper